9 from the Nine Worlds

Many readers expressed immense delight in returning to the world and beloved characters of the Magnus Chase series. Reviewers consistently praised the book for its signature humor, light-hearted tone, and entertaining adventures, making it a joy to read. The collection of short stories, each narrated by a different "side character," was appreciated for giving these fan favorites a chance to shine and explore the various realms of Norse mythology. A particular highlight for many was the unique overarching element of Thor's peculiar and often chaotic journey across the nine worlds, driven by an unconventional goal, which provided a continuous thread of amusement throughout the book. The inclusion of stunning illustrations was also noted as a welcome addition.

Despite the overall positive reception, some common criticisms emerged. A significant point of contention for many was the notable absence of Magnus Chase himself, with several readers expressing a wish for his narration or presence. Similarly, some hoped for more interaction between specific popular characters, rather than primarily solo missions. While the short story format was generally liked, a few reviewers felt that some individual narratives lacked distinct personality or depth, missing an opportunity to delve further into the characters as individuals or to explore the different worlds more thoroughly. A minor point was that the book sometimes felt very specific to its middle-grade target audience.

Overall, this collection of short stories is widely regarded as a fun and refreshing companion to the Magnus Chase series. It delivers the author's characteristic wit and engaging style, offering a chance to reconnect with a cherished cast of characters and the imaginative Norse world. This book is highly recommended for existing fans of the Magnus Chase trilogy who are eager for more light-hearted adventures with their favorite Hotel Valhalla residents and are prepared for a different narrative style without the main protagonist. It serves as a delightful epilogue for those who missed the series and wish to revisit its unique blend of mythology and humor.