Positives The book is highly regarded as a very readable and detailed account of World War Two's impact on Aberdeen and its surrounding areas. Reviewers specifically commend its honest portrayal of the challenges faced by civilians, including the horrors of bombing and the lack of defense, as well as the author's willingness to address government incompetence, miscommunication, and inter-organizational infighting. It is celebrated as a valuable addition to local history archives, documenting the resilience and fortitude of the local people, and is considered an accessible read for both casual readers and those with a deeper interest in the subject. Many appreciated the opportunity to learn about their hometown's wartime experiences and the contributions of local military personnel.
Negatives The primary criticism leveled against the book concerns the quality of many of its photographs. While acknowledging that some originals likely came from older sources such as newspapers, reviewers felt that modern technology could have been utilized to enhance these images to a higher degree, improving their overall presentation within the book.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered a good and valuable resource, offering significant insights into a specific period of history. It comes highly recommended for anyone with personal ties to Aberdeen or a general interest in local history and the impact of major global events on specific communities. Its detailed yet accessible nature makes it suitable for both dedicated history enthusiasts and those simply curious about the wartime experiences of the region.
