Aberdeen Beyond the Granite

This book has garnered praise for its notable success, evidenced by its eight editions published since 2010, indicating a strong and lasting appeal among readers. A significant draw is its engagement with local history, a subject that has proven to be very popular. Additionally, the book is appreciated for its psychogeographical approach, which involves a reflective exploration of places and a musing on the feelings they evoke.

On the other hand, some feedback suggests a potential issue with the book's tone. It has been described as "stuck up," implying a certain pretentiousness or an overly academic style that might not resonate with everyone. This characteristic could be a point of contention for readers who prefer a more accessible or less self-important narrative voice.

Overall, this book is a successful work that particularly appeals to those interested in local history presented through a contemplative and emotionally resonant lens of psychogeography. It would likely be enjoyed by readers who appreciate a thoughtful and reflective exploration of places and their impact, and who are comfortable with a narrative style that some might perceive as sophisticated or even a bit highbrow.