Above Ground

Reviewers largely celebrate Clint Smith's latest poetry collection for its tender and insightful exploration of parenthood. Many praise its ability to capture the profound joys, frustrations, and everyday moments of raising children, particularly from a father's perspective. The collection is noted for its authentic portrayal of love, wonder, and the shift in priorities that comes with having a family, often described as relatable and emotionally resonant without becoming overly sentimental. Readers highlight how Smith skillfully juxtaposes these intimate family experiences with the broader complexities and challenges of the world, creating a powerful balance between personal narrative and social commentary. The poetry is frequently lauded for its accessibility, making it an excellent entry point for those new to the genre, with its straightforward yet affecting language that evokes a wide range of emotions.

While overwhelmingly positive, a few reviews offered minor criticisms. One reader felt that despite the undeniable poignancy of the poems, they remained somewhat on the surface, lacking a deeper emotional urgency or rhythm that would foster a stronger connection. Another reviewer expressed a strong personal disconnect, finding the focus on celebrating parenthood and heteronormativity unengaging and even annoying, preferring not to delve into the author's personal life or intimate moments. Additionally, some observed that the narrative style of the poems, while contributing to their accessibility, occasionally made the collection read more like a memoir with line breaks rather than showcasing extensive poetic experimentation.

Overall, the collection is highly recommended, frequently earning top ratings for its powerful and moving content. It is celebrated as a "stunning" and "fantastic" rumination on family, lineage, and legacy that many readers found themselves revisiting. This book is particularly well-suited for parents, especially new fathers, who will likely find deep resonance in its depiction of modern fatherhood. It is also an ideal choice for readers who are generally hesitant about poetry, as its approachable style and clear thematic focus serve as an excellent introduction to the genre. Ultimately, "Above Ground" offers a thought-provoking experience for anyone seeking to reflect on the interplay between personal life and the wider world, and who appreciates a blend of vulnerability, love, and social awareness in their reading.