Ada

The book is widely praised for its beautiful graphic design and overall luxurious presentation, which many reviewers found appealing. A significant positive highlighted across reviews is the crucial importance of its subject matter: the expulsion of Germans from Olomouc after World War II. This is frequently described as a vital, often overlooked or undiscussed historical topic. Reviewers appreciate the book for being educational, powerful, and supported by historical sources, offering what some describe as an honestly processed story rooted in the author's family history. Many feel it successfully raises crucial awareness about a complex period.

However, the book also drew several criticisms regarding its execution. Some reviewers noted that it struggles to maintain a coherent novelistic form, often feeling more like a narrative that becomes rushed and somewhat unfinished towards the end. Specific points of contention include dialogues that were perceived as unnatural and contemporary sections that were found to be unengaging or artificial. A significant concern raised by multiple reviewers is the book's perceived lack of objectivity; it is described by some as presenting a black-and-white view with a tone of grievance and a one-sided portrayal that omits crucial historical context, such as the actions of Germans before and during the war. The author's writing style was also mentioned as not always fitting the gravity of the subject matter.

In conclusion, this book tackles a profoundly important and sensitive historical subject, offering a unique perspective often rooted in personal family history. While lauded for its educational value and beautiful presentation, its narrative structure and perceived bias in historical interpretation may not appeal to all readers. It would particularly resonate with those interested in the lesser-known aspects of post-World War II history in Central Europe, specifically the experiences of Germans in Czechoslovakia, and readers who appreciate books that spark discussion on complex historical grievances, even if they present a particular viewpoint. However, readers seeking a strictly objective, comprehensive academic analysis or a well-structured, impartial novel might find certain aspects of the book less satisfying.