Always Matt A Tribute to Matthew Shepard

Reviewers widely praise this book as a beautiful and powerful tribute to Matthew Shepard, recognizing its success in keeping his memory alive and honoring his impact. Many readers found the book profoundly moving, eliciting strong emotional responses including tears, and noted its ability to convey a sense of Matt's character and the injustice of his story. The author's choice to tell the story in spare, simple verse, often leaving significant empty space on the page, is frequently highlighted as an effective artistic choice that mirrors the void left by his death. The deeply moving and exquisite illustrations are consistently lauded for enhancing the narrative and capturing both Matt's likeness and the emotional tone. Additionally, the inclusion of a foreword by Jason Collins and an extensive epilogue with resources, notes, and a bibliography are appreciated for providing context and encouraging further action.

While overwhelmingly positive, some reviewers expressed minor reservations. A recurring point of discussion is the book's format and intended audience, with some finding it confusingly positioned between a graphic novel and a picture book, and questioning whether its simple style is aimed at young children or older readers and adults. One reviewer felt the poetic style did not always read like traditional poetry, and another noted a minor inconsistency in mentioning "angels" at the trial versus the funeral. The intense nature of some illustrations, though powerful, was mentioned as potentially jarring. A few readers also felt the book, while a beautiful memorial, was not comprehensive in detailing Matt's life and death, serving more as a reflective piece than a full biography.

Overall, this book is highly recommended as a poignant and essential work that continues Matthew Shepard's legacy. It is seen as a crucial tool for fostering greater understanding and acceptance within the LGBTQ+ community and for reminding readers of the ongoing fight against hatred. While its format may prompt discussion, its emotional impact and important message resonate deeply with those already familiar with Matt's story, as well as those new to it. It is particularly suited for readers seeking a heartfelt, accessible, and visually evocative tribute, including upper elementary to middle graders, educators, counselors, and adults interested in LGBTQ+ history and social justice.