Amantes dos reis de Portugal

The reviews highlight the book as a competent and engaging summary of Portuguese history, uniquely presented through the marital and extramarital lives of its monarchs. Many readers found the theme fascinating and curious, appreciating how it makes history accessible and quick to read. It's praised for not being a mere "pink magazine" style enumeration of affairs, but rather offering a rigorous socio-cultural framing of the Portuguese monarchy and its political history across four dynasties. The book is seen as providing interesting insights and knowledge, making it a recommended read for those seeking an overview of the royal house.

However, some reviewers expressed concerns regarding the book's depth and approach. Criticisms include a perceived lack of empathy and deep reflection concerning historical figures, with some feeling the narrative leaned too heavily on historical "gossip" or superficial accounts. Specific mention was made of a "terrible" or unfounded treatment of certain female historical figures. Some felt the authors did not delve deeply enough into the subject matter, leading to a less academic or deeply historiographical work. Additionally, a few readers found the reading experience somewhat "arid" or slow due to the exhaustive detailing of royal liaisons, making it a demanding read at times.

In conclusion, the book appears to be a mixed bag, generally perceived as interesting and worthwhile, though not without its flaws. It offers a valuable, albeit lighter, journey through Portuguese history, blending personal intrigue with broader historical context. This book would particularly appeal to readers interested in an accessible, engaging overview of the Portuguese monarchy's personal lives and their historical backdrop, without requiring a deeply academic or highly empathetic study. It is well-suited for those who enjoy historical narratives that prioritize readability and broad coverage over intensive, scholarly analysis or profound character development.