Ararat (Nominatie Ako Literatuurprijs 2007) (In Dutch Language)

The reviews frequently praise "Ararat: In Search of the Mythical Mountain" as a rich and multifaceted work, blending memoir, history, travelogue, and philosophical meditation. Readers found it an engaging and educational exploration of various themes, including religious beliefs, ancient flood narratives, geology, volcanology, and the complexities of political borders surrounding Mount Ararat. Many appreciated the author's personal journey, tracing his childhood fascination with the Noah's Ark story through his adult adoption of scientific values and subsequent re-evaluation of faith. The book is lauded for its academic yet accessible approach to complex topics, its thorough research, and a lively, fluent English translation. Its complete and deep nature, offering a unique blend of personal reflection with broader historical and scientific inquiry, resonated positively with many.

Despite its strengths, some reviewers found aspects of the book less compelling. A common criticism points to the writing style as occasionally dry or matter-of-fact, making it difficult for some to connect with emotionally. While the book covers many topics, some felt the narrative could meander, with certain personal reflections or tangents being less interesting than the central themes. A few reviewers perceived the author's strong stance on atheism as overly emphasized, at times coming across as "evangelical atheism" or a "tacky hate" for religious belief, which detracted from the overall experience. Others wished for a more focused narrative, feeling that the book delved too much into the author's personal life rather than the mountain, the region, or the Ark itself. The pacing was also mentioned, with the actual climb occupying only a small portion of the book, and some found the ending abrupt, lacking a clear climax or definitive conclusion.

Overall, "Ararat" is considered a thought-provoking and ambitious book that defies easy categorization. It is highly recommended for curious readers interested in the intricate interplay between science and religion, personal quests for meaning, and the historical and cultural significance of a mythical location. Those who appreciate non-fiction that blends genres, offers deep intellectual exploration, and is rich in journalistic detail and literary prose are likely to find it rewarding. However, readers seeking a straightforward adventure story, a clear-cut plot, or a definitive resolution to the science-versus-faith debate might find its meandering style and lack of a traditional conclusion less satisfying. It particularly appeals to those open to delving into the author's internal journey and grappling with complex ideas without expecting easy answers.