Athēna

Reviewers generally praise this book for its pleasant and engaging presentation of the myths surrounding the creation of Athens. Many found the author's approach to be enjoyable, combining knowledge with humor and an accessible, everyday style that prevents the subject matter from becoming tedious. The book is commended for its ability to organize complex mythological narratives, providing readers with a clear sequence of events concerning the ancient kings and their deeds without getting lost in the details. It is seen as a valuable resource for those curious about the mythological origins of Athens before its classical period, offering interesting stories and even some interpretations of cultural identity.

Conversely, some readers expressed significant reservations about the book. Criticisms include a perceived narrow focus on only the kings in Athenian mythology, questioning if this truly represents the full scope of the subject. There were concerns about the inclusion of seemingly irrelevant content, such as mentions of other historical groups in the epilogue, which was seen as out of place in a mythological context. The writing style itself was a point of contention, with one reviewer suggesting it lacked conciseness and felt drawn out. Questions were also raised regarding the author's selection process for myths, implying arbitrary choices about what to include or omit, and a lack of clear sourcing for historical dates. Ultimately, for some, the book was considered unengaging and a missed opportunity.

In summary, the book appears to be a polarizing read. While it successfully captivates those seeking an entertaining and well-organized introduction to Athenian foundational myths, presented with humor and clarity, it falls short for readers expecting rigorous academic depth, comprehensive mythological coverage, or a consistently tight narrative. It would likely appeal most to readers with a general interest in ancient Greek mythology and history who appreciate an accessible, lighthearted approach to learning, and who are looking for an enjoyable overview rather than an exhaustive scholarly analysis.