Positives The book is widely praised as essential and required reading, offering profound insights into the ongoing "women's question" and the manipulation of media in a way rarely seen. Reviewers laud its ability to provide a deep understanding of the historical and cultural forces that push back against women's progress, showing how arguments against gender equality are universal and cyclical. Many highlight its comprehensive and exhaustively researched nature, with chapters dedicated to specific themes like media, politics, fashion, and psychology, all rich with examples. Despite its often bleak subject matter, the book is consistently described as bringing hope by showcasing women's perseverance and inspiring readers to be more critical of information. Its brilliant writing and strong analysis of popular culture, including TV and film, are frequently commended, with many noting that it laid the groundwork for subsequent feminist works.
Negatives While largely positive, several reviewers found the book to be a challenging and often depressing read, with its exploration of persistent inequalities sometimes evoking anger. Some felt the length, at over 400 pages, made it a demanding commitment. Although many emphasize its continued relevance, a few acknowledge that some of the cultural references and anecdotes, being from the 1980s, can feel dated. One reviewer mentioned an "undertone of anger" that made it difficult to finish, and another described it as "clearly biased" while still powerful. The book's heavy focus on American context was also noted by one reader, though others found its principles universally applicable.
Conclusion Overall, the consensus is that this book remains an incredibly powerful and timely work, crucial for understanding how little things have changed and how much work still needs to be done in the fight for gender equality. It is highly recommended for anyone seeking to understand the historical backdrop of women's rights and the subtle yet pervasive forces that impede social change. Readers interested in feminism, sociology, media literacy, or simply wishing to question societal assumptions about women will find it invaluable. It is particularly suggested for those open to a meticulously researched account of the "undeclared war" against women and how to effectively resist it.
