Positives Reviewers widely praise "Why The Whales Came" as a beautifully written and compelling story, often described as a "page-turner" and a "gem." Michael Morpurgo's exemplary writing style is highlighted for its ability to create vivid imagery and a poetic atmosphere, immersing readers in the setting. The narrative is lauded for its authenticity, particularly in depicting a way of life on the Scilly Isles during the First World War. Readers appreciate the intriguing plot, which includes elements of mystery, suspense, and historical echoes, all while delivering a heartwarming experience. The book's strong themes of friendship, courage, trust, respect for nature, and overcoming prejudice resonate deeply, showcasing Morpurgo at his best.
Negatives While overwhelmingly positive, some reviews note a few minor drawbacks. A common observation is that the story can be slow to start, with some readers finding the initial chapters less engaging or even "a bit boring" before the plot becomes more active and captivating. A few adult readers, particularly those familiar with Morpurgo's other works, felt that this particular book, while good, might not be as emotionally impactful or "ongoing" as some of his other acclaimed titles. Additionally, specific elements like the "superstition and curse aspect" were not to everyone's taste, and some wished for more focus on the titular whales, feeling they appeared relatively late in the narrative.
Conclusion Despite these minor points, the overall consensus is that "Why The Whales Came" is a brilliant and highly recommended novel from a master storyteller. It offers a rich blend of adventure, historical context, and moral messages that resonate with a wide audience. This book is ideal for young readers, typically from 5th through 8th grades, but is also thoroughly enjoyed by adults who appreciate well-crafted stories. It appeals to those who enjoy coming-of-age tales, narratives set in unique historical locations, and stories that explore themes of friendship, bravery, community, and the importance of nature conservation. It is particularly recommended for fans of Morpurgo's storytelling style and lovers of narwhals.
