Positives The book is praised as an impactful and systematic examination of the many challenges facing the school system. Readers appreciate how it methodically explains the various reforms and measures that have influenced educational practices. It is noted for presenting examples of how other countries have successfully turned around negative educational trends, offering a comparative perspective. Furthermore, the author is seen as having an open-minded approach, willing to consider ideas that traditionalists in the school debate might otherwise dismiss.
Negatives A significant point of criticism is the book's predominantly negative tone, with a large portion of its pages dedicated to describing the perceived decline and issues within the school system, particularly since the 1990s. Some reviewers found this extensive focus on problems to be disheartening, even labeling it as potentially "traumatizing" for parents. The book was also described by some as being a bit slow or tedious at times. Additionally, some readers noted that the author's underlying ideological perspective occasionally becomes apparent.
Conclusion In conclusion, this book offers a critical and comprehensive analysis of educational reforms and their consequences, providing a detailed account of the challenges within the school system. It is best suited for readers who are deeply interested in understanding the historical development and current state of educational policy, especially those concerned with the impact of reforms enacted since the 1990s. Parents, educators, and individuals seeking a thorough, albeit often critical, exploration of systemic issues in education would find this book insightful, provided they are prepared for its largely problem-focused narrative.
