Positives Reviewers largely commend Derecka Purnell's book for its clear, empathetic, and patient explanation of abolitionist concepts. Many found it an indispensable read for understanding real solutions to systemic issues, praising the author's ability to break down complex ideas with specific examples and supportive evidence. The book is highlighted for its compelling blend of personal narrative, detailing Purnell's own intellectual and political evolution, with historical, sociological, and legal analysis. Its strengths lie in making the idea of abolition accessible and even inevitable, inspiring readers to critically rethink their reliance on existing systems. Furthermore, the book is lauded for its sharp intersectional analysis, connecting abolition to disability justice, climate justice, anti-capitalism, and anti-imperialism, and for activating the "radical imagination" by offering a vision of a more just society.
Negatives However, the book also drew criticism, primarily concerning its structure and presentation. Several reviewers found the writing style disjointed, discursive, and at times hard to follow, with frequent tangents and a lack of clear thematic coherence. Issues with editing, proofreading, and typos were noted, suggesting a rushed publication process. Some arguments were perceived as underdeveloped or lacking in depth, particularly in later chapters concerning topics like capitalism and socialism. Readers expecting a detailed "how-to" guide or specific policy prescriptions for achieving abolition were often left dissatisfied, feeling that practical questions remained unanswered. Additionally, some felt the book assumed a certain level of prior familiarity with abolitionist movements and organizations, potentially making it less accessible for those entirely new to the subject.
Conclusion Despite these structural and editorial shortcomings, the book is widely regarded as a valuable and important contribution to the literature on abolition. It is strongly recommended for anyone interested in social justice, the prison industrial complex, and understanding the broad implications of the abolitionist movement. The book particularly resonates with "abolition-curious" readers, those open to evolving their perspectives, or individuals seeking an empathetic and comprehensive overview that challenges conventional thinking. While some suggest it might not be the absolute first read for a complete novice, many others endorse it as an excellent starting point or for those looking to deepen their understanding, especially if they are skeptical or primarily view abolition as a reductive process. It also serves as an inspiring read for seasoned activists seeking fresh intersectional analysis.
