Black and Blue

Reviewers widely praise this novel as a prime example of Ian Rankin's skill, highlighting its deep connection to American noir fiction rather than traditional British whodunits. The protagonist, Detective Inspector John Rebus, is consistently lauded as a complex, hardened, and determined character, whose cynical yet sharp-witted approach to tracking down criminals, often regardless of his superiors' wishes, makes him compelling. Rankin is celebrated for his masterful storytelling, literary writing, and exceptional dialogue, which combine to create a vast, intricate, and often witty narrative. The book is also commended for its vivid portrayal of modern Scotland, exploring the underbelly of Edinburgh and other Scottish cities, as well as the social and political issues of its time, such as the North Sea oil industry. Its constant action, multiple intertwined plotlines, and strong sense of place contribute to a highly engaging and immersive reading experience.

While many reviewers found the intricate plot a strength, some noted that its complexity could be challenging, making it difficult to follow all the twists and numerous characters without close attention. The sheer number of interwoven storylines and places visited was, for a few readers, overwhelming, leading to a sense of exhaustion or a desire for a more focused narrative. Some found the pacing slow in the initial stages, with a prolonged build-up before the various plots converged. Additionally, while Rebus's character is generally admired, his maverick tendencies and disregard for police procedure were occasionally seen as unrealistic, and the portrayal of him temporarily abstaining from alcohol was met with mixed reactions, with one reviewer finding it disappointing. A minor point of critique was a lack of innate interest in the detailed exploration of the Scottish oil industry for some.

Overall, this novel is frequently cited as a standout in the series, marking a significant turning point in Ian Rankin's career and solidifying his reputation as a major force in Scottish crime fiction, underscored by its Gold Dagger award. It is an intelligent and rewarding read, despite its demands on the reader. This book is particularly recommended for those who appreciate complex, multi-layered crime novels that delve deeply into character and setting. Readers who enjoy hard-boiled detective stories with a flawed but compelling protagonist, a strong sense of place, and a rich social commentary on contemporary Scotland will find this book highly satisfying. It appeals to fans of Tartan Noir and those who value literary quality within the crime genre, offering a gripping and thought-provoking journey.