Burned Alive
by Souad
- First published 2003
- 359 pages
- English
At seventeen, Souad fell in love in her West Bank village. When she became pregnant, her family deemed it a dishonor punishable by death. Her brother-in-law carried out the sentence, dousing her with gasoline and setting her on fire. Miraculously, Souad survived the attack, rescued by women from her village who took her to a local hospital. Despite her family's continued attempts to end her life, a European aid worker intervened, securing the care and sanctuary Souad desperately needed.
Now living in permanent exile, Souad shares her story as a testimony to her survival and a call to action against the widespread practice of honor killings. This memoir details her harrowing ordeal, her struggle to live through critical burns, and her determination to forge a new life. It reveals the brutality of a tradition that continues to this day, offering a direct account of one woman's fight for existence and her resolve to speak for others.
What readers say
4.11
17K ratings across the web 8 in 10 readers loved it
Many readers found this book to be a profoundly moving and impactful experience, serving as a powerful eye-opener to the horrific realities faced by women in certain parts of the world, particularly within a traditional Palestinian village setting as depicted. Reviewers praised its ability to evoke strong emotions, describing it as shocking, stirring, and harrowing. The narrative is often lauded for raising crucial awareness about honor crimes and the extreme subjugation of women, prompting readers to reflect on fundamental human values and their own good fortune. Even those who questioned its factual basis acknowledged the book's effectiveness in highlighting serious global issues and inspiring discussions about social justice, education, and the fight against barbaric traditions. Many applauded the protagonist's depicted strength and courage, finding her story of survival and resilience inspiring.
Despite its emotional impact, the book has drawn significant criticism, primarily concerning its authenticity and presentation. A recurring negative point is the contention that the book is not a true memoir but a work of fiction masquerading as fact, with some reviewers citing historical and cultural inaccuracies and even impossible events described within the narrative. This perceived deception led to accusations of exploiting a serious issue for profit, preying on Western anxieties, and promoting xenophobic stereotypes, particularly by depicting Westerners as saviors and Arabs/Muslims as inherently barbaric, with some readers from the Middle East feeling the book misrepresented Palestinian culture. Other criticisms include poor writing quality, a repetitive and incoherent narrative, tragic translation issues, and a generally pessimistic tone. Some reviewers also noted factual errors regarding local customs and language, and felt the book oversimplified complex social systems or failed to acknowledge any positive aspects of the cultural upbringing it portrays.
Ultimately, the reception of this book is deeply divided, largely hinging on whether readers accept it as a true account or a fictionalized narrative. Regardless of its veracity, many agree that the book powerfully conveys the existence of extreme cruelty and oppression against women in certain societies. It is a book recommended for readers who are not faint of heart and are prepared for a challenging, emotionally draining experience. It appeals to those interested in stories of survival, human rights, and cultural disparities, and who are willing to engage with a narrative that sparks intense debate. While some are disgusted by its potential fabrication, others believe its core message about the struggles women endure remains vital, making it a valuable, albeit controversial, tool for raising awareness and fostering dialogue on global issues of gender inequality and violence.
Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first.
Details & editions
- This edition
- Corgi, 2005
- ISBN
- 9780552213264
- Language
- English
Original edition Brûlée vive Originally published in 2003 · French · OH Editions









