Bílý pramen

The book is appreciated for its interesting portrayal of life in the Sudetenland before the war, following the journey of its main character, Hedviga. While some found Hedviga's story unique to her character, even if broadly perceived as a common narrative, readers generally found it engaging and satisfying, delivering what they expected. The emotional depth of the story, particularly the ending which depicts Hedviga's humble reflection on her life, resonated positively with reviewers. Additionally, the book is recognized as a commendable debut effort by the author, earning praise for her achievement.

However, several reviewers expressed reservations about the book's writing style and overall execution. The prose is described as impersonal and detached, making it difficult for some readers to connect deeply with the characters or feel fully immersed in the story. Critics also noted a perceived lack of originality, with the narrative sometimes feeling like "idle chatter" or lacking a strong central plot thread, leading to a sense that the story was "too ordinarily" written and offered little new insight or perspective. Specific criticisms also included the author's inconsistent or thoughtless combination of Czech and German names and places.

In conclusion, this book offers a mixed experience for readers. While it successfully delivers a poignant character study set against a rich historical backdrop for some, others found its execution to be conventional and its style too distant. It appears to appeal most to readers interested in historical fiction set in the Sudetenland, particularly those who appreciate a focus on personal reflection and character development over a fast-paced or highly original plot. Readers who value a debut author's effort and a straightforward narrative about ordinary lives in a specific historical context may find this book a worthwhile read, especially if they are not seeking groundbreaking literary innovation or deep emotional immersion with every character.