Positives The reviews consistently praise this book as a monumental and deeply insightful work, offering a comprehensive and often harrowing account of the contemporary Middle East. Readers highlight its ability to provide a nuanced understanding of the region's complex history, particularly regarding the forces that shaped it post-World War Two, and the West's involvement. Robert Fisk is widely lauded for his journalistic integrity, courage, and dedication to reporting from the front lines, often choosing to operate independently rather than being "embedded" with military forces. His writing is described as powerful, unflinching, and empathetic, focusing on the human cost of conflict by giving voice to victims and challenging conventional narratives. Many found the book to be a profoundly impactful experience, capable of shifting their perspectives and prompting critical reflection on global events and media portrayals.
Negatives Despite its strengths, the book receives criticism for its considerable length, with some reviewers finding it excessively long and at times disorganized. The narrative can feel repetitive or rambling, and some readers suggested that better editing could have condensed the content without losing its essence. A recurring point of contention is Fisk's perceived strong pro-Arab stance, which some argue leads him to gloss over the failings of Middle Eastern nations while heavily scrutinizing Western and Israeli actions. While appreciated by many for its critical perspective on Western policies, others felt this approach sometimes bordered on propaganda or contained minor historical inaccuracies. Additionally, some personal anecdotes, such as those concerning Fisk's father, were deemed irrelevant or distracting from the main historical narrative. The book's relentless depiction of atrocities, while praised for its honesty, also made it an emotionally challenging read, leaving some feeling despairing or without hope.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered an essential and highly recommended, albeit demanding, read for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the Middle East's turbulent history and its ongoing conflicts. It is particularly suited for readers interested in challenging mainstream media narratives and exploring the devastating human impact of war and political interventions. While its length and certain stylistic choices might require patience, the book's profound insights into geopolitical dynamics and its unwavering focus on the experiences of ordinary people make it a unique and valuable contribution to historical journalism. It is recommended for those willing to confront uncomfortable truths and engage with a passionate, firsthand account of decades of strife, even if it offers few easy answers or glimmers of hope.
