Catatan Jenderal Pranoto Reksosamodra dari RTM Boedi Oetomo sampai Nirbaya

The book is praised as an engaging memoir and biography of Major General Pranoto Reksosamodra, offering a significant historical account. It chronicles his journey through various military ranks, from his early days to becoming a high-ranking officer in the TNI-AD. Readers learn about his participation in crucial historical events, such as the Kotabaru incident and the General Offensive of March 1st, 1949, and his tenure in important military positions. The memoir is valued for providing a unique perspective on the early New Order era, shedding light on a "fragment of the story" often overlooked and presenting a valuable "second opinion" on the historical event of G30S. It is considered an important testimony that enriches understanding of the nation's history, aiming to present a true historical account.

While offering valuable insights, the memoir is noted for not providing extensive detail in its storytelling, meaning some narratives within the book may lack the depth or elaboration that some readers might expect. The book also recounts the severe personal trials faced by Pranoto and his family, including his unjust accusation of involvement in the G30S event, which led to the destruction of his career and his imprisonment without sufficient evidence. While this challenging period is a central and impactful part of the book's narrative, the review implies the book focuses on presenting the events and his experience rather than delving into the minutiae of every aspect.

Overall, the book is considered a valuable and worthwhile read, particularly for its contribution to historical understanding. It serves as an essential historical testimony, offering readers a crucial alternative perspective on the historical event of G30S and the tumultuous early years of a new political order. This memoir is highly recommended for readers interested in Indonesian history, especially those seeking to understand the complexities of the G30S event and the subsequent New Order era from a perspective beyond the official narratives. It appeals to those who wish to explore the experiences of individuals who faced severe consequences during this pivotal period.