Chosen by God

Reviewers widely praise R.C. Sproul's "Chosen by God" as a clear, concise, and accessible introduction to the Reformed perspective on predestination and related doctrines. Many highlight Sproul's ability to explain complex theological and philosophical ideas with remarkable clarity, utilizing short, pithy sentences and logical arguments that make the book engaging and easy to understand. Readers frequently describe the book as life-altering and transformative, profoundly shaping their understanding of God's sovereignty in salvation and fostering a deeper appreciation for divine grace. The author's tone is consistently lauded for being thoughtful, gentle, and non-militant, avoiding the vitriol often found in discussions of this topic. Instead, Sproul is seen as presenting a strong biblical case for his views while respectfully addressing common objections and alternative interpretations, ultimately leading many to a more glorious and comforting view of God.

Despite widespread acclaim, some reviewers expressed significant reservations about certain aspects of "Chosen by God." A common criticism centers on a perceived shift in tone in the latter half of the book, which some found to become judgmental and uncompromising, leaving little room for differing interpretations. Several readers felt that Sproul misrepresented or did not fully understand opposing theological viewpoints, leading to arguments against positions that their adherents would not recognize. Others were left with unanswered questions, feeling that Sproul occasionally relied on "the mystery of God" as an explanation for complex or seemingly unreasonable divine actions, rather than providing convincing theological resolutions. For some, the book's theological conclusions, particularly regarding the extent of divine love or the fate of humanity, were deeply troubling and led to a rejection of the core tenets presented. A few also noted that while the book is biblical, it sometimes leans more philosophical, and some found other authors' treatments of the subject more compelling.

"Chosen by God" emerges as a highly influential and often transformative work for those exploring the doctrines of grace. It is celebrated for its clarity, logical coherence, and its capacity to deepen readers' appreciation for God's sovereignty. While its gentle and accessible approach is a major strength, some readers found its later arguments unyielding or felt it failed to adequately address certain ethical and theological dilemmas. This book is highly recommended for readers new to or curious about the Reformed perspective on predestination, as well as those seeking a robust, biblically-grounded defense of this view. It is particularly valuable for individuals willing to grapple with challenging theological concepts and potentially re-evaluate their existing understanding of God's nature and humanity's role in salvation.