Positives "Columbus Day" is widely praised by many readers as a highly entertaining and engaging military science fiction novel. Reviewers frequently highlight its compelling humor, witty dialogue, and banter, which often escalates to hilarious levels, particularly after the introduction of a charismatic sidekick character. The main protagonist is often described as likable, adaptable, and a "kinda sorta hero by accident," making for an enjoyable point of view. The audiobook narration by R.C. Bray receives consistent accolades, with many listeners crediting his performance for significantly enhancing the experience and bringing the characters and story to life. Many found the plot engrossing, the action robust, and appreciated the balance between serious sci-fi elements and lighthearted moments.
Negatives However, the book is not without its criticisms. A significant number of reviewers point to issues with editing, citing numerous grammatical errors, typos, redundant passages, and overall sloppiness that detracted from their reading experience. Some found the writing style immature, corny, or excessively repetitive. While the humor was a strong positive for many, others felt it was over-the-top, glib, or juvenile, with "dad jokes" and explained pop culture references hindering the flow. Character development was also a point of contention; some found the main character uninteresting or monopolizing the narrative, while others described secondary characters as underdeveloped or forgettable. The pacing, particularly in the first half, was sometimes described as a "slog" due to exposition and military jargon, and certain plot resolutions were seen as too convenient.
Conclusion Overall, "Columbus Day" appears to be a polarizing read, eliciting strong positive and negative reactions. It is generally recommended for readers who enjoy military science fiction, especially those who appreciate a strong vein of humor and don't mind a less serious, "brain candy" approach to the genre. Fans of audiobooks are particularly encouraged to try it due to the highly praised narration. However, those seeking deep character development, meticulous editing, or a more serious, thought-provoking narrative may find its flaws too distracting. It’s best suited for those looking for a fun, action-packed space romp with plenty of laughs.