Positives Eric Schlosser's Command and Control is widely lauded by reviewers as a profoundly important, meticulously researched, and utterly compelling book that exposes the precarious reality of nuclear weapons safety. Many readers found the narrative to be an eye-opening and terrifying account, effectively shattering any illusion of complete control over these devastating devices. The book's strength lies in its comprehensive detail, drawing from declassified documents and personal interviews to construct a thorough history of the US nuclear arsenal. Reviewers frequently praise Schlosser's engaging writing style, which manages to make a highly technical subject accessible and often reads with the tension of a thriller, particularly when detailing specific incidents. The book's capacity to evoke strong emotional reactions, from shock to profound unease, is a testament to its powerful message and the author's skill in illustrating humanity's numerous close calls with accidental nuclear catastrophe due to systemic vulnerabilities and human error.
Negatives Despite its many strengths, some readers noted that the book can occasionally be weighed down by its extensive detail, leading to a slower pace. Critics mentioned instances where Schlosser provides exhaustive backgrounds of numerous individuals or delves into lengthy technical descriptions, which some felt could detract from the central narrative's urgency. A few reviewers wished for a more concise presentation and found the prose to be "bloodless" at times, despite the life-and-death scenarios being described. Additionally, some felt the book's historical scope could have been extended to more thoroughly cover nuclear weapons in the post-Reagan era, including the context of modern terrorism, or to offer a more balanced perspective on the command and control challenges faced by other nuclear powers beyond the US. A minor criticism also concerned the index, which some found insufficient for navigating the book's dense information.
Conclusion Overall, Command and Control is highly recommended as an essential and sobering read, offering a crucial, albeit unsettling, examination of global security. The overwhelming consensus is that the world has been incredibly fortunate to avoid widespread accidental nuclear detonations, attributing this more to sheer luck and the dedication of individuals than to infallible systems. The book powerfully conveys that the greatest risks have often originated from within the nuclear programs themselves. This work is particularly well-suited for readers interested in military history, nuclear policy, or investigative journalism, as well as anyone concerned about global stability and the inherent dangers of complex technological systems. It is consistently described as a meticulously researched account that challenges prevailing assumptions and leaves a lasting, thought-provoking impression about the fragility of our collective safety.
