Positives The book is widely praised as an excellent and essential read, offering a profoundly illuminating and eye-opening perspective on the history of the United States. Reviewers consistently highlight how it unearths a "hidden" or "forgotten" narrative of American empire and its territories, surprising even seasoned history enthusiasts with previously unknown details about places like the Philippines, Puerto Rico, and the Guano Islands. Readers commend the author's accessible, conversational, and engaging writing style, which transforms a dense academic subject into a highly readable and often humorous account. The book's thorough research and broad scope are frequently noted, tracing US expansion from its earliest days through its overseas acquisitions and the evolution of its global influence. Many find it highly relevant, connecting historical events to a deeper understanding of contemporary US power and its impact on the world.
Negatives While largely positive, some reviewers express reservations, particularly regarding the book's latter sections. A common criticism is that the narrative occasionally strays into tangents, such as the history of specific companies or the standardization of everyday objects, which some felt detracted from the core argument about US empire. Critics also point to perceived omissions or a lack of in-depth analysis on certain aspects of modern US global power, including the role of international financial institutions or significant military interventions post-World War II. Some argue that the author employs a narrow definition of colonialism, focusing primarily on direct territorial control, which may overlook subtler forms of indirect influence or neo-colonialism. A few reviewers also suggested that the historical portrayal, while impactful, could sometimes lean towards a less balanced or overly critical journalistic tone in certain discussions.
Conclusion Despite these criticisms, the overwhelming consensus is that this book is a significant and highly recommended work of history. It successfully challenges conventional understandings of American identity and its global role, prompting readers to reconsider the nation's past and present. The book serves as a vital resource for anyone interested in a more complete and nuanced understanding of US history, particularly those parts often overlooked in mainstream narratives. It is highly recommended for general readers, history enthusiasts, and even students seeking an engaging and accessible exploration of US expansionism, its territories, and the evolving nature of its global power, ultimately offering a thought-provoking look at the consequences and legacy of its influence.
