Dans l'ombre d'April

The book is largely praised for its compelling and captivating mystery, drawing readers into a thrilling whodunnit set against the atmospheric backdrop of Oxford University. Many reviewers found the narrative well-written and engaging, appreciating the author's ability to create a sense of intrigue and cast doubt on various characters. The dynamic between the central group of friends, particularly the magnetic "It Girl" April, is frequently highlighted as a strong point, effectively setting the stage for the unfolding drama. For many, the story offered smart twists and a satisfying conclusion that kept them guessing until the very end.

However, a significant number of readers expressed concerns regarding the book's pacing and length, often finding parts of the middle section to be slow, repetitive, or unnecessarily drawn out. Some felt the plot lacked originality, presenting a familiar storyline that didn't offer fresh twists. The main protagonist, Hannah, received mixed reception, with several reviewers describing her as dull, indecisive, or overly passive, which made it difficult for them to connect with her journey. Additionally, while the Oxford setting was appreciated, some felt the "dark academia" elements were more superficial, serving as a backdrop rather than a deeply integrated theme.

Overall, opinions on the book are somewhat divided, ranging from a strong recommendation for fans of the author to a "perfectly fine" or even disappointing read for others. It is likely to appeal most to readers who enjoy character-driven psychological thrillers, particularly those set in college environments with a central murder mystery to unravel. Fans of Ruth Ware's previous works, who appreciate her signature style and enjoy unraveling a complex web of suspects and motives, will likely find this a worthwhile read. However, those seeking a fast-paced, highly original plot or a protagonist with a more assertive personality might find themselves less engaged.