Dari hukum kolonial ke hukum nasional suatu kajian tentang dinamika sosial-politik dalam perkembangan hukum selama satu setengah abad di Indonesia, 1840-1990

The reviews highly praise the book for its significant contribution to the understanding of Indonesian legal history. Reviewers commend the author's ability to effectively present the complex transition from colonial law to national law, even noting his skill despite not holding a traditional law professorship. The book is lauded for its captivating narrative quality and its critical perspective on legal development, covering a broad period from the colonial to the post-colonial era. It is seen as a valuable addition to historiography, offering a nuanced view of the shift from a subjugated society to an independent one, emphasizing the various underlying currents that led to independence rather than just armed conflict. Many consider it a masterpiece deserving of collection.

While the content of the book receives overwhelming acclaim, one reviewer notes a specific drawback concerning different editions. The newer edition is described as less appealing than earlier versions, primarily due to the omission of the author's insightful preface, which provided behind-the-scenes context for the writing process. Additionally, the newer edition is considered less portable, making it less convenient for readers who might wish to carry it as a travel companion. These points, however, pertain to the physical presentation and supplementary material of specific editions, rather than the core academic quality or narrative of the work itself.

In conclusion, this book stands out as an essential and highly recommended work in the field of legal history and historiography. It offers profound insights into the evolution of law in Indonesia and the intricate processes of societal transformation. It would particularly appeal to readers interested in legal history, the dynamics of post-colonial transitions, and those seeking a detailed, critical, and engaging account of how legal systems adapt and change. Potential readers might want to consider which edition they acquire, keeping in mind the noted differences in supplementary content and physical format.