Dari Soekarno Sampai SBY (Indonesian Edition)

This book offers unique and intimate insights into the communication styles, habits, and decision-making processes of Indonesian presidents, from Soekarno to SBY. Reviewers consistently praise its engaging, often humorous, and accessible approach to a political subject, making it an entertaining read that also broadens understanding. The author is commended for creating a book rich in data, drawing from interviews with over 25 individuals who worked closely with the presidents, presenting their raw and original narratives. Many highlight its unique content, offering "inside stories" and details not typically found in other sources, with specific chapters dedicated to each president's key traits like communication patterns, anger, and reactions to criticism, sometimes including unique characteristics that add to its appeal. The book is lauded for making a complex topic light and enjoyable, even serving as a valuable academic reference for some.

However, some reviewers noted issues with the book's flow and overall balance, suggesting certain sections felt less developed or disproportionately weighted. Specifically, the coverage of the then-current president (SBY) was perceived as less candid, relying more on publicly known information rather than exclusive insider accounts, with limited sources. Concerns were also raised about the representation of certain presidents; Soekarno's section was deemed too brief and focused mainly on his final period, while Gus Dur and Habibie were sometimes portrayed in a more negative light. Conversely, the section on Soeharto was considered by some to be overly extensive. Despite efforts for objectivity, a slight bias, particularly towards Soeharto, was observed by a reviewer, leading to calls for a more updated and objective future edition.

Overall, this book provides a fascinating and often amusing journey into the personalities and leadership styles of Indonesian presidents, successfully transforming a potentially heavy political topic into an accessible and enjoyable read. It is highly recommended for readers interested in a unique, behind-the-scenes look at Indonesian political figures, particularly those who appreciate anecdotal insights and a blend of historical context with humor. This book would appeal to anyone seeking to understand the human element of presidential leadership, offering both entertainment and valuable perspective on the nation's past leaders, despite some perceived imbalances in coverage and focus.