De dónde venimos los cholos

The book is widely praised for its direct, honest, and engaging prose, which reviewers describe as agile, clear, and personal. Readers found themselves captivated and transported by the author's ability to balance anecdotal detail with broader reflections on identity and migration. Many highlight the book's success in exploring the rich cultural and human tapestry of Peru, particularly its diverse communities, traditions, landscapes, and iconic foods. The narratives are often described as eye-opening, revealing various realities of the country's interior that are often overlooked from the capital. Reviewers appreciated how the book prompts readers to question their own ideas about origin and identity within the Peruvian context, offering a different and unique vision of the country.

Despite strong praise, some reviewers noted a perceived shift in focus towards the latter part of the book. While the chronicles on Peruvian gastronomy are well-written, a common sentiment was that they felt somewhat disconnected from the initial premise of exploring "cholo" identity, particularly when the narrative concentrated heavily on Lima. This led to a feeling that the book didn't fully answer the question posed in its title, or that the central theme became less clear. Other criticisms included a desire for more representation of coastal life, observations of exoticism in descriptions of indigenous communities, and a lack of a more aggressive or critical stance on social and political issues, such as the "gastronomic boom" or societal inequalities. One reviewer also pointed out instances of problematic descriptions related to body image.

Overall, "De dónde venimos los cholos?" is highly recommended as a valuable and enjoyable read that offers a profound journey into Peru's diverse realities. While it may not provide a definitive anthropological answer to its titular question, it effectively presents a collection of compelling stories and experiences that broaden understanding of the country's complex identity. This book is considered essential reading for Peruvians, particularly those residing in large cities, as it sheds light on overlooked regions and people, fostering self-knowledge and empathy. It is also highly recommended for anyone interested in gaining a deeper, nuanced understanding of Peru's cultural context, its people, and the ongoing dialogue surrounding identity and social issues.