Des chats par millions

The book "Millions of Cats" is widely celebrated as a classic, noted for being the oldest American picture book still in print and a Newbery Honor title. Reviewers praise its short, simple, and engaging narrative, often described as a whimsical and imaginative adventure with a charming fairy-tale feel. Many appreciate the unique black and white illustrations, which are considered adorable, expressive, and possess a folk motif style, contributing to the book's timeless appeal. The repetitive, sing-song refrain is highlighted as making it an excellent choice for reading aloud. Readers frequently find the story entertaining and intriguing, enjoying its straightforward storytelling and the relatable premise of struggling to choose just one cat. It is cherished by many as a childhood favorite, leaving a lasting impression of its quaint charm.

Despite its classic status, some readers express reservations about "Millions of Cats." A recurring concern centers on the story's resolution, which some find disturbing, dreadful, creepy, or even gruesome, particularly for younger children. This aspect has led some to question its suitability for today's child audience, describing it as anachronistic or overly cruel. A few reviewers also found the black and white illustrations unappealing, likening the masses of cats to faceless swarms rather than individual characters. From a children's librarian perspective, one reviewer felt the book contained too much text and not enough engaging pictures, leading to a lack of lasting impression for some readers and their children. Others felt the narrative left them feeling cold or found the old couple's actions indicative of irresponsibility.

Overall, "Millions of Cats" remains a significant and often beloved children's book, though it elicits a range of strong opinions. It is widely interpreted as a cautionary tale, exploring themes such as vanity, the subjective nature of beauty, human responsibility, and the consequences of excess. While its "dark twist" may not appeal to all, many appreciate its unique blend of traditional fairy tale elements with a surprising edge, often finding a humorous or profound message within. This book would likely appeal to readers who appreciate classic children's literature, enjoy stories with a clear moral, and are open to narratives that don't shy away from implied, fantastical consequences. It is particularly recommended for those who enjoy read-aloud sessions and a story that sparks discussion, though parents of very young or sensitive children might wish to preview it.