Diane Arbus

The collection is widely celebrated as a masterful and profoundly influential work in photography, described as original, genius, and a classic that significantly impacted the art form and even cinema. Reviewers consistently praise its disturbing, haunting, and affecting quality, noting how it compels viewers to confront "differentness" and their own perceptions. The photographs are lauded for their power, intensity, and ability to create an exhilaratingly intimate connection with their subjects, often portraying them with empathy and respect. Many appreciate Diane Arbus's unique vision and philosophy, highlighting her skill in capturing aspects of humanity that might otherwise go unseen. The book itself is frequently commended for its exceptional production quality, featuring beautiful reproductions that have stood the test of time, alongside an insightful introduction from Arbus.

Despite the widespread acclaim, some reviewers express reservations about the collection's perceived unevenness, suggesting it contains "filler" or "simple snapshots" alongside truly exceptional "gems." Specific criticisms include technical flaws such as overexposure, film development marks, or less effective composition in certain photographs. A notable point of contention involves ethical concerns regarding Arbus's approach to her subjects; some question whether she exploited them or presented them in an unduly "harsh" light, leading to feelings of discomfort or even offense among certain readers, particularly those who identify with marginalized groups. Additionally, the introductory text by Arbus, while interesting, is occasionally described as "scrambled," "fragmentary," or lacking a cohesive structure, and some readers desired more context or background stories for the individual photographs.

Ultimately, this book is widely regarded as an essential monograph and a landmark work for anyone interested in the history of photography and the exploration of diverse human experiences. It is highly recommended for readers who appreciate powerful, thought-provoking portraiture that challenges societal norms and delves into the complexities of human identity. While certain aspects, such as the subject matter or Arbus's methodology, may be ethically challenging or technically inconsistent for some, the collection is overwhelmingly celebrated for its artistic impact and its capacity to evoke strong emotional and intellectual responses. It will particularly resonate with artists, photographers, and anyone seeking a profound, often unsettling, artistic experience that pushes boundaries and encourages deep introspection.