Die 5. Plage / The 5th Horseman

Many readers found this fifth installment of the Women's Murder Club series to be an engaging and highly readable thriller. Reviewers consistently praised the fast pace, short and punchy chapters, and the overall ease of reading, which makes it hard to put down. The book is described as having the usual James Patterson twists and turns, with some appreciating the drama, suspense, and a surprising ending. The writing style is often called snappy, entertaining, and compelling, providing an enjoyable "brain candy" experience. Some readers particularly liked the inclusion of courtroom drama and felt the series picked up speed with this volume, with one of the club members, Yuki, receiving more focus. The characters are generally considered likeable, making it feel like catching up with friends for series fans.

However, the book also drew significant criticism, primarily for its fragmented plot structure. Many reviewers felt there was too much going on, with two distinct storylines – one involving mysterious deaths in a hospital and another concerning murdered young women – that often felt disconnected and sacrificed plausibility, in-depth character development, and satisfying resolutions. Some found the plots to be over-the-top, uninspired, or "samey" compared to other books by the author. There were complaints about unrealistic character interactions, such as frequent hugging among professional women at crime scenes, and dialogue that felt cheesy. Medical professionals specifically noted a lack of accurate research regarding hospital procedures and medication administration, finding some arguments in the courtroom scenes to be far-fetched. Others felt certain character arcs fizzled out or were poorly integrated, and some found the ending abrupt or lacking sufficient explanation for how key mysteries were solved.

Overall, "The 5th Horseman" appears to be a divisive entry in the Women's Murder Club series. While it delivers the signature fast-paced, easy-to-read thriller style that James Patterson fans enjoy, its execution of multiple plotlines and character dynamics left many readers wanting more depth and cohesion. Despite its narrative shortcomings, many still found it diverting and enjoyable enough for a quick read, making it suitable for those seeking light, entertaining suspense for a vacation or casual reading. Avid James Patterson enthusiasts and readers who prioritize a rapid plot over intricate detail and realism are most likely to appreciate this book, especially if they are already invested in the series.