Positives Reviewers generally commend J.M.G. Le Clézio's acclaimed writing style, often described as poetic, limpid, and powerful, which masterfully applies feelings like touches of paint. The book is lauded for transcending a mere biography, presenting instead a rich "mythology" or "affresco" that skillfully interweaves the personal lives of Diego Rivera and Frida Kahlo with the broader political and social landscape of early 20th-century Mexico. Readers appreciate how the author balances the couple's suffering and intense love with the historical context, allowing the characters to appear vibrant and alive. The narrative is praised for its comprehensive scope, exploring their travels, political engagements, and the profound influence of their unique, often tumultuous, relationship on their artistic creation. Many found the book to be well-documented, drawing from interviews, diaries, and autobiographies, offering a faithful and evocative portrait that makes the figures come to life.
Negatives Despite the praise, some reviewers expressed disappointment, primarily regarding the book's perceived imbalance in focus. Several felt that Diego Rivera often overshadowed Frida Kahlo, with her story presented more in parallel to his, thus diminishing her individual presence. Critics sometimes found Le Clézio's tone overly hyperbolic, mystical, or, in certain sections, dispassionate or even verbose, leading to a less engaging reading experience, particularly in the first part. Some felt that while the book was well-documented, it occasionally omitted deeper explorations of certain life aspects or didn't provide fundamentally new insights for those already familiar with the artists. Additionally, a few readers found the extensive detail on political and revolutionary contexts, while appreciated by others, to be tedious or too dominant, detracting from the personal narrative they sought.
Conclusion Ultimately, Le Clézio's work is seen as a compelling blend of historical reconstruction and literary narrative, offering a nuanced and non-simplistic understanding of Diego Rivera and Frida Kahlo. It delves into their intertwined lives, their art, and the cultural tapestry of their time, portraying their relationship as an "indissoluble bond" that fueled their creativity. This book is highly recommended for art enthusiasts, particularly those interested in Mexican history and culture, and readers who seek a deeper, more complex portrayal of the famous couple beyond conventional narratives. It appeals to those who appreciate a literary approach to biography, focusing on the broader impact of personal lives on artistic expression and the world around them, rather than a straightforward chronological account solely centered on one figure.
