Dit was oorlog : van afkak tot bosbefok ; Suid-Afrikaanse dienspligtiges praat

The book is widely praised for its insightful and humanizing portrayal of the South African Border War, offering a unique collection of personal anecdotes from national servicemen. Readers found it highly informative, providing crucial background and understanding of an often-overlooked period in history, particularly for South Africans and those with family connections to the conflict. Reviewers appreciated the book's multifaceted approach, presenting diverse perspectives from various individuals, which contributed to its emotional depth and impact. The narratives are described as brutally honest, stripping away propaganda and heroic myths to reveal the raw experiences of soldiers, including their bravery, resilience, camaraderie, and the often-harrowing realities they faced. Many found the accounts deeply affecting, making for a compelling and historically significant read that sheds light on the lived experiences of those who served.

Despite its strengths, some readers identified areas for improvement or found aspects of the book challenging. A recurring criticism was the perceived repetitiveness in some sections, with certain stories or themes reappearing without significant new development. Some reviewers also felt the book could have benefited from a broader scope, such as including a foreword from a senior military figure or more diverse experiences. A significant point of contention for one reviewer was the book's underlying perspective, which they felt focused excessively on the conscripts' hardships without adequately contextualizing the wider suffering caused by the apartheid system, viewing it as a limited lens that overlooked the experiences of millions. Additionally, while valued for its honesty, the book's unflinching depiction of military incompetence, political deception, and the psychological toll on servicemen made it an uncomfortable and difficult read for some.

Overall, "An Unpopular War" is regarded as an important and impactful book, offering valuable insights into a complex and often painful chapter of South African history. It is highly recommended for South Africans seeking to understand the legacy of the Border War and its effects on individuals, as well as for military historians, veterans, and anyone interested in personal accounts of conflict. Readers who appreciate history told through the eyes of those who lived it, rather than from an academic distance, will find this book particularly compelling. However, its direct and often stark portrayal of war, coupled with its specific focus, means it may not appeal to all readers, especially those seeking a broader political analysis or a more traditional historical overview. It is best suited for those prepared for a challenging, emotionally resonant, and deeply personal exploration of a "forgotten war."