Elsku drauma mín minningabók Sigríðar Halldórsdóttur

Reviewers widely praise the book for its beautiful writing and engaging narrative style. Many found it a delightful and enjoyable read, often exceeding initial expectations. The book offers a unique and intimate insight into the life at Gljúfrasteinn, presented through a feminist lens that many appreciated. The structure, which is non-linear and requires readers to piece together events, was noted as an interesting and effective approach. Readers highlighted the presence of numerous short, often charming, and sometimes humorous anecdotes, as well as impactful stories. The effortless and wonderful storytelling, particularly how Vigdís Gríms captures the narrator's voice, received significant commendation.

Despite the praise, some readers found the book to be overly personal, akin to a family album or casual coffee talk that might not fully resonate with outsiders. While the everyday stories were often beautiful, some reviewers reported losing interest in them quickly. There was also a sentiment that the book could be a slow read at times, particularly in the beginning, though it often picked up pace later. A few felt that the inclusion of letters occasionally detracted from the overall flow and the author's usual word mastery. One particularly critical review labeled the book as boring, criticizing it for focusing on a privileged life and praising offspring. Some readers who had specific expectations, perhaps based on other works, found the narrative more subdued than anticipated or noted a limited scope in certain areas.

Overall, the book appears to be a deeply personal and beautifully written account that offers a unique perspective on family life and a notable figure, framed with a strong feminist viewpoint. While its intimate nature might not appeal to all, those who appreciate a non-linear narrative, a focus on everyday life and memories, and a distinct authorial voice are likely to enjoy it. It is particularly recommended for readers interested in personal histories, family dynamics, and works that explore life from a specific, reflective perspective, especially if they value strong, evocative writing that draws them into the narrator's world. Readers who prefer fast-paced plots or extensive biographical details about public figures might find it less engaging.