Fallen

The reviews for this book highlight several positive aspects that appealed to some readers. Many consistently praised the book's gorgeous and alluring cover, which often drew them in. Some reviewers appreciated the dark and edgy atmosphere, as well as the overarching premise of fallen angels and an ancient war. They found the story's dynamic elements gripping and, for some, even addictive, despite acknowledging a slow initial pace. The two main love interests, Daniel and Cam, were described as captivating and sexy, contributing to a compelling love triangle. For these readers, the book successfully built suspense and developed its characters, ultimately setting the stage for what they hoped would be an exciting series with promising twists.

However, a significant number of reviews expressed strong criticisms, particularly regarding the writing quality, which was frequently described as poor, with choppy sentences, awkward phrasing, and a general lack of polish. The protagonist, Luce, drew widespread criticism for being passive, dim-witted, and lacking self-respect, often engaging in problematic "stalker" behavior. The central romance was largely deemed unconvincing and unhealthy, with the male lead, Daniel, often treating Luce poorly, and their connection feeling forced due to a perceived lack of genuine chemistry or character development. Critics also pointed out the exceedingly slow and uneventful pacing, with many feeling that little plot progression occurred until the final chapters. This left numerous questions unanswered, contributing to a sense that the overall story was shallow, predictable, and derivative of other popular paranormal romances, particularly the Twilight series. Some reviewers also noted outdated or potentially offensive social portrayals and a perceived lack of research into the mythological elements.

Overall, the reviews for this book are sharply divided, with a considerable number expressing extreme dissatisfaction. While some readers found the first book enjoyable enough to consider continuing the series, many others described it as a frustrating, dull, and ultimately unfulfilling read. The book is generally recommended for younger teen readers, particularly those who enjoy the tropes common in early 2000s paranormal romance, such as a mysterious school setting, a love triangle, and powerful romantic leads, especially fans of the Twilight series. However, more critical or discerning readers, particularly those seeking originality, strong character development, or well-executed plots, are likely to find it disappointing.