Fanny Hill la fille de joie

Name: Fanny Hill la fille de joie
Rating: 6.52 (13516 reviews)
Author: John Cleland
ISBN: 9782868699510

Language: French
Published in: 1993
Publisher: Actes Sud
Pages: 122
ISBN: 9782868699510

Subjects

Original edition details

Fanny Hill Originally published in 1961

Original language

English

Original publisher ReadHowYouWant.com

Other editions (237)

Memoirs of Fanny Hill (Annotated)

2021 • Independently Published

English

Fanny Hill Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure

2015 • CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform

English

Fanny Hill Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure

2015 • CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform

English

Fanny Hill Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure

2002 • Wildside Press, LLC

English

Fanny Hill (Harper Perennial Forbidden Classics)

2010 • HarperCollins UK

English

6.52 / 10 (13K ratings)

Reviews summary

Positives

Reviewers widely praise the book for its historical significance, recognizing it as one of the earliest pornographic novels in English literature. Many highlight its groundbreaking nature for the 18th century and its enduring reputation, despite being banned for centuries. Readers frequently found it surprisingly humorous and entertaining, appreciating its bawdy wit and the author's inventive use of euphemisms for anatomical terms and sexual acts. The prose is often described as elegant, poetic, and tender, elevating the subject matter beyond mere vulgarity. Some also noted a peculiar feminism within the text, presenting a female protagonist who actively seeks and enjoys sexual pleasure without shame, gaining a degree of agency and self-awareness that challenged conventional moralistic narratives of the era. The novel is thus seen as offering valuable insight into 18th-century social attitudes and the origins of erotic fiction.

Negatives

Conversely, many reviewers found the book to be highly repetitive, particularly in its descriptions of sexual encounters, which often became dull and unstimulating for modern sensibilities. The plot is frequently criticized as thin, ridiculous, or merely a series of disconnected episodes rather than a cohesive narrative, contributing to a feeling of sloppiness and a lack of engaging character development. Modern readers also encountered problematic elements, including the male author's perspective on female sexuality, which could feel inauthentic or objectifying, and instances where consent was ambiguously portrayed or disturbing acts were presented without sufficient critical distance. Reviewers also noted misogynistic undertones and a lack of realism regarding women's experiences in the period, such as the "happy hooker" cliché. Additionally, the protagonist's strong disapproval of certain sexual acts, particularly homosexuality, was found to be contradictory and offensive by some.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the book is widely regarded as a significant historical curiosity and a foundational text in the history of erotic literature, rather than a universally engaging literary masterpiece for today's audience. While it offers a unique glimpse into 18th-century fantasies and the evolution of sexual discourse in writing, its repetitive nature and dated perspectives on gender and sexuality can make it a challenging read. It is recommended for those interested in literary history, the development of the erotic genre, or readers who can appreciate its humor and linguistic inventiveness while acknowledging its problematic aspects. It may not appeal to those seeking a compelling plot, deep character development, or consistently "hot" contemporary erotica.

No reviews yet. Be the first to review this book!

Rating sources

Subjects

Original edition details

Other editions (237)

Memoirs of Fanny Hill (Annotated)

Fanny Hill Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure

Fanny Hill Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure

Fanny Hill Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure

Fanny Hill (Harper Perennial Forbidden Classics)