Fiqh madzhab negara kritik atas politik hukum Islam di Indonesia

The book is highly praised for its critical and insightful analysis of the New Order State's policies concerning Islamic law. It offers a fresh and thought-provoking perspective, directly challenging the notion that the state genuinely accommodated Islamic interests during its later years. Reviewers appreciate its rigorous approach, which delves into the political dimensions underlying legal frameworks and policies. By using specific case studies, the book effectively demonstrates its arguments and encourages readers to critically examine the true beneficiaries and motivations behind state actions.

The provided reviews do not explicitly detail any significant drawbacks or criticisms regarding the book's quality, writing style, or research methodology. Instead, the primary review focuses on summarizing the book's own critical arguments and conclusions about the New Order era's policies. While the book itself presents a critical analysis of historical events, the reviews do not offer a counter-critique of the book's approach or execution.

Overall, the book is presented as a significant and insightful contribution to understanding the complex relationship between state power and Islamic law during the New Order period. It offers a powerful counter-narrative to conventional views, urging readers to reflect on the independence of religion from state influence. This book would be particularly valuable for readers interested in Indonesian political history, the sociology of law, or the dynamics of religion and state in authoritarian contexts. It is likely to appeal to academics, students, and anyone seeking a rigorous, critical analysis of how political power shapes legal frameworks and potentially co-opts religious elements for state objectives.