Forever . . .

The book is widely praised for its pioneering and honest portrayal of teenage love and sexuality, particularly for its time of publication in the 1970s. Reviewers frequently highlight its refreshing realism in depicting a first serious relationship, including sexual experiences, without resorting to common tropes of punishment or tragedy for the characters involved. Many appreciate its sex-positive message, openly discussing topics like birth control, consent, and responsible choices, often portraying supportive parental figures and demystifying resources like Planned Parenthood. Readers, especially those who encountered it in their youth, found the story relatable, reflecting the intense emotions, awkwardness, and sometimes shallow nature of adolescent romance. The book is commended for challenging societal double standards and slut-shaming, presenting sex as a normal part of life and emphasizing the importance of consensual and enjoyable experiences, even if the love doesn't last "forever."

Despite its groundbreaking themes, many contemporary readers express significant reservations, primarily concerning the book's literary execution. A frequent complaint is the writing style, which is often described as bland, unimaginative, and dry, with numerous reviewers finding the constant use of ellipses particularly irritating and disruptive to the reading flow. Critics also point to a perceived lack of character development, with some finding the protagonist, Katherine, occasionally boring and her love interest, Michael, often depicted as overly focused on sex and pushy. The portrayal of their relationship is sometimes seen as lacking genuine chemistry or emotional depth, making the narrative feel rushed or like a public service announcement rather than a compelling story. Specific details, such as Michael naming his penis, are frequently cited as cringeworthy or unromantic, further detracting from the reading experience for some.

Overall, the book garners a mixed reception, valued more for its historical importance and candid approach to sensitive subjects than for its literary artistry by modern standards. It is recognized as a crucial and groundbreaking work for its era, offering a much-needed, realistic perspective on teenage sexuality when such discussions were largely taboo. While some aspects feel dated, its core themes of first love, personal choices, and navigating relationships remain relevant. This book is particularly recommended for young adults, especially teenage girls, who are beginning to explore their own understanding of relationships and sexuality, offering an unromanticized, honest look at these experiences. It would also appeal to readers interested in the evolution of young adult literature and those who appreciate its role in fostering open conversations about sexual health and personal responsibility.