French Illuminated Manuscripts in the J. Paul Getty Museum

The book is highly praised for its visually appealing content, specifically for the very nice plates showcasing selections from the collection.

However, several criticisms are raised regarding the depth of information provided. The captions are noted as being too brief, leaving readers unfamiliar with the symbolic idiom depicted with many unanswered questions. Furthermore, the reviewer expresses a wish for a broader scope, noting that the book focuses entirely on miniatures and omits detailed views of other spectacular elements, such as marginal patterns.

Overall, the book offers a strong visual presentation but may fall short for those seeking comprehensive contextual information or a wider exploration of the collection's various elements. It would likely appeal most to readers who appreciate high-quality visual reproductions and are perhaps already somewhat familiar with the subject matter, or those looking primarily for an aesthetic experience rather than in-depth analysis.