Positives The reviews highlight the book as an engaging and informative journey into Brazil's profound passion for football. Readers praise its ability to skillfully connect the sport with the nation's rich culture, history, and national identity, offering a panoramic view that explores diverse aspects such as racism, political corruption, social life, religious beliefs, superstitions, and the vibrant carnival spirit. The author's distinctive journalistic style is commended for bringing to life the unique Brazilian playing style, characterized by spontaneity, individual flair, and a dance-like quality. The book is rich with curious facts, compelling anecdotes, and literary references, providing a deep understanding of how football has shaped, and been shaped by, Brazilian society. Many found it entertaining, humorous, and well-researched, making them feel as though they were taking a historical, human, and even political tour of the country.
Negatives Despite its strengths, several reviewers noted some structural and pacing issues within the book. Criticisms include a perceived lack of organization, with the author occasionally deviating into tangential details that can make transitions between historical and contemporary events feel confusing. Some readers felt the book could benefit from being more concise and that certain sections tended to drag. A few wished for a more focused history of the game itself, including major teams and coaches on the pitch, suggesting the coverage was sometimes selective. Additionally, while generally well-written, some found the language to be occasionally dry or overly report-like. A minor point raised was that the book, originally published in 2002 with a 2014 update, is starting to show its age and could benefit from a further revision to remain current.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered a valuable and insightful read for anyone interested in Brazilian football or the country itself. It is highly recommended for football enthusiasts, particularly those fascinated by the unique magic and history of the Brazilian game. Beyond sports fans, the book appeals to readers keen on understanding Brazilian culture, society, and politics, as football serves as an inseparable lens through which these complex topics are explored. Its ability to weave together diverse elements, from the emergence of legendary players to the enduring impact of historical events, makes it a compelling socio-political history. Even those not inherently passionate about football may find it a rewarding experience for its broader cultural insights, inspiring a deeper appreciation for Brazil and even a desire to visit.
