Geger Pacinan, 1740-1743: persekutuan Tionghoa-Jawa melawan VOC

The book is widely praised as an essential read for anyone interested in Indonesian history, particularly the often-overlooked contributions and deep historical connections of the Chinese community in the archipelago. Reviewers highlight its success in illuminating the significant and beneficial influence of Chinese immigrants on Javanese society and its development, emphasizing how their trade and knowledge fostered early harmony and acculturation, a stark contrast to colonial exploitation. The book is commended for presenting a comprehensive historical account of a major, largely forgotten alliance between Chinese and Javanese communities against Dutch colonial forces in the mid-18th century. It is seen as a valuable resource for understanding the socio-economic-cultural dynamics of this multi-ethnic society, their joint resistance, and the subsequent colonial strategies to divide them. Many readers appreciate its detailed, chronologically presented narrative, often sourced from primary documents, which offers a fresh perspective on inter-ethnic relations and challenges narrow, negative historical views, fostering a sense of connection to shared cultural roots and promoting understanding.

While overwhelmingly positive, the reviews do present a minor critique regarding the author's consistency in historical details. One reviewer points out a specific instance where a Javanese king, Pakubuwana I, is referred to with the title "Sultan" in one chapter, which is historically inaccurate for that period according to the reviewer's understanding of Mataram royalty and the requirements for that title. This suggests a potential for occasional inconsistencies or minor historical errors within the text. Additionally, one review mentions "some typos," indicating a slight lack of polish in the editing.

Overall, this book is highly recommended as a compelling and important historical work that brings to light a crucial, yet often neglected, chapter in Indonesian history. It serves as a powerful testament to the historical solidarity and shared struggles between Chinese and Javanese communities against colonial rule. The book is particularly suited for history enthusiasts, scholars of Southeast Asian history, and general readers interested in understanding the complex tapestry of Indonesia's multi-ethnic past. It would especially appeal to those seeking to challenge pre-conceived notions about ethnic relations, appreciate the depth of historical acculturation, and learn about significant acts of resistance against colonialism, ultimately fostering a more nuanced and inclusive understanding of national identity.