Gozashte Zamaneh

The book is described as charming and delightful, offering valuable insights into the history of the country. Reviewers particularly appreciated the initial sections, which are noted for being eloquent, coherent, and enjoyable. These early parts delve into the author's family and social conditions in Iran, and are highlighted for their focus on prominent literary figures, especially Sadegh Hedayat, providing a captivating glimpse into their lives and friendships.

However, several significant criticisms are raised regarding the book's presentation and later content. A major concern is the severe lack of editing and chapter divisions, with some reviewers suggesting the publisher merely reproduced the author's original manuscripts without proper refinement. This unedited state made the book difficult for some to read or even finish. Furthermore, the latter half of the book is criticized for shifting into a more personal and grievance-filled narrative, focusing heavily on the author's complaints against political party leaders, which some felt turned the work into a personal settling of scores. The ending is also noted as abrupt and lacking a clear conclusion.

In conclusion, while the book offers historical value and engaging early sections, its structural and editorial shortcomings, coupled with a highly personal second half, detract from the overall reading experience for some. It is primarily recommended for readers with a specific interest in the life and works of Bozorg Alavi, the literary circle around Sadegh Hedayat, or the historical context of the Tudeh Party. Those seeking a polished, well-structured narrative or a purely objective historical account may find it challenging.