Positives Reviewers largely commend the book for its meticulous research and comprehensive chronicling of U.S. foreign policy and covert operations since 9/11. Many highlight its rigorous, fact-based approach, presenting a detailed history of unacknowledged violence and the evolution of American legal standards. The book is praised for shedding light on the roles of the CIA, Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC), and the continuity of policies across the Bush and Obama administrations. Readers appreciate its ability to back assertions with evidence while weaving compelling real-life stories, offering an in-depth look at a subject often ignored or superficially covered by mainstream media.
Negatives However, some reviewers express concerns regarding the book's objectivity, pointing to a perceived political bias and a one-sided narrative that consistently portrays the U.S. government in a negative light. Critics suggest the author sometimes integrates hyperbole with facts, leading to a sensationalist tone that might feel more like an opinion piece or extended magazine article than a balanced historical account. Issues with pacing are also noted, with some finding the extensive factual detail and statistics occasionally dense or repetitive. A few reviewers also raise questions about specific factual inaccuracies and the book's failure to adequately explore the rationales or intended effectiveness of the U.S. policies it criticizes.
Conclusion Despite these criticisms, the book is widely regarded as an important and powerful work, offering a critical perspective on America's post-9/11 "War on Terror." It is highly recommended for readers interested in foreign policy, civil liberties, and the history of covert military and intelligence operations. The book is particularly likely to resonate with those who hold anti-war sentiments or are skeptical of U.S. government actions abroad, providing a valuable, albeit challenging, examination of the ethical and strategic consequences of these interventions. Ultimately, many consider it an essential read for anyone concerned about America's role in the world.
