Hamsun

The reviews highly praise this biography as a near-perfect and exceptionally thorough work. It is meticulously documented with a vast array of primary sources, including letters, newspaper articles, notes, journals, and diary fragments, which builds strong trust in the material presented. The biographer is commended for impressively connecting the subject's life, the surrounding societal context, and his literary works, offering valuable insights into the historical development of Norway and Europe from the late 19th century through the post-war period. This approach deepens readers' understanding of his books and the evolution of his writing. A significant positive is the book's nuanced portrayal of the subject, highlighting complexities in his controversial political views and actions, such as efforts to challenge the brutality of the occupation and attempts to aid prisoners and Jewish people. For audiobook listeners, the narrator receives particular acclaim for an engaging reading style and a spot-on imitation of the subject's voice in direct quotes.

Despite its strengths, the biography's extensive detail, while contributing to its thoroughness, can be somewhat overwhelming for some readers. The book is described as an emotionally stirring experience due to its unflinching depiction of the subject as a difficult, self-centered, and often irrational individual. It candidly explores his possessiveness, contrarian nature, and his disturbing relationship with Nazism, without glossing over these challenging aspects. The narrative also includes uncomfortable details, such as additional insights into the post-war legal proceedings against him and how professional fields were utilized, which can make for difficult reading. Ultimately, some reviewers suggest the book might primarily appeal to those with a specific or special interest in the subject matter.

Overall, this biography is highly regarded, with one reviewer awarding it a 4.5 out of 5. It successfully delivers a comprehensive, objective, and balanced view of a deeply complex and controversial figure. The book is recommended for readers interested in Norwegian history, literary biographies, and those seeking a deeply researched and nuanced account of a challenging personality. It is particularly suitable for individuals who wish to understand the intricate societal and political backdrop that shaped the subject's life and work. Prospective readers should be prepared for an intense and highly detailed exploration of a flawed genius.