
Hillbilly Elegy [movie Tie-In] A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis
by J. D. Vance
7.66 / 10 515K ratings
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2020
- Publisher
- HarperCollins Publishers
- Pages
- 288
- ISBN
- 9780063045989
From a Rust Belt town in Ohio, J. D. Vance offers a passionate and personal analysis of a culture in crisis - that of white working-class Appalachians. Through the lens of his own chaotic upbringing, he tells the true story of what social, regional, and class decline feels like. Vance's family story begins hopefully when his grandparents move north from Kentucky in search of a better life. They achieve a middle-class existence, and their grandson would eventually graduate from Yale Law School, a conventional marker of achieving the American Dream. This success, however, is only part of the story.
This memoir reveals how the Vance family was haunted by the legacy of abuse, alcoholism, poverty, and trauma characteristic of their community. Vance shows how he himself still carries the demons of his turbulent family history, never fully escaping the struggles of his roots. With piercing honesty, Hillbilly Elegy becomes an urgent and troubling meditation on the loss of the American dream for a large segment of the country and explores what it truly means to overcome hardship without forgetting where you come from.
This memoir reveals how the Vance family was haunted by the legacy of abuse, alcoholism, poverty, and trauma characteristic of their community. Vance shows how he himself still carries the demons of his turbulent family history, never fully escaping the struggles of his roots. With piercing honesty, Hillbilly Elegy becomes an urgent and troubling meditation on the loss of the American dream for a large segment of the country and explores what it truly means to overcome hardship without forgetting where you come from.
Subjects
- Historical
- United States
- History
- Biographies & Memoirs
- Cooking
- Memoirs
- Political
- Family
- Case studies
- Economic Conditions
- Essays
- Psychology
- Politics & Social Sciences
- Faith
- Social Sciences
- Business & Economics
- Biography & Autobiography
- Women
- Literary Collections
- Sociology
- Religion
- Social Science
- Political science
- Cultural, Ethnic & Regional
- Personal Memoirs
- Rural
- Ethnic Studies
- Violence in Society
- American
- State & Local
- Social Psychology
- Anthropology
- Religion, Politics & State
- Cultural & Social
- Canadian
- Economic History
- Political Economy
- Social Classes & Economic Disparity
- Poverty
- Poverty & Homelessness
- Biography
- Social Conditions
- Class
Original edition
Hillbilly Elegy A Memoir of a Family and Culture in CrisisOriginally published in 2016 English Harpercollins
Other editions (23)
Listen to the summary Narrated summary
I remember the endless cycle of moving, the parade of men in my mother's life, and the shouting that often punctuated our days. It was a childhood steeped in the chaotic rhythm of a poor Rust Belt town, Middletown, Ohio, a place where the promise of industry had long since faded, leaving behind a profound sense of loss and stagnation. My family, like many, had migrated from the hills of Kentucky, bringing with them the fierce independence and deep-seated loyalties of Appalachia, but also its demons. We were a people defined by our roots, even when those roots became tangled in the struggles of a new, unforgiving landscape.
My earliest memories are vivid with the presence of Mamaw and Papaw, my maternal grandparents, the bedrock in a turbulent sea. They had sought a better life after World War II, leaving behind the grinding poverty of Kentucky for the steel mills of Ohio, hoping to secure a middle-class future. Yet, the transition was never complete. The “hillbilly” ways, the feuds, the quick tempers, the struggles with alcohol and abuse, followed them, casting long shadows over subsequent generations. Mamaw, with her tough exterior and unwavering love, was a force of nature, capable of both terrifying rage and profound tenderness. She was the one who instilled in me a sense of discipline and a glimmer of hope that a different path was possible.
My mother, a bright woman in her own right, was caught in a relentless eddy of addiction and instability. Her relationships were a series of explosions and implosions, each one leaving more emotional debris in its wake. I watched as she battled her demons, and I often bore the brunt of the fallout. It was a painful cycle to witness, and even more so to live through, as the constant uncertainty chipped away at any sense of security. Despite her struggles, she worked hard as a nurse, trying to provide, but the chaos of her personal life often overshadowed her efforts.
The schools I attended reflected the brokenness around me. It was easy to fall into the trap of low expectations, to believe that my future was predetermined by my past. I dabbled in alcohol and weed, nearly failing my first year of high school. But somewhere amidst the turmoil, a flicker of ambition ignited, fueled by Mamaw's fierce belief in me and the stark realization that I did not want to repeat the patterns I saw everywhere. I spent a significant amount of time with Mamaw and my biological father, who, despite his own issues, offered a different kind of stability.
Joining the Marines after high school was a pivotal decision, a deliberate break from the familiar chaos. It offered structure, discipline, and a sense of purpose I hadn't known before. It was a chance to prove to myself, and to the world, that I could rise above my circumstances. The military taught me resilience and gave me the tools to navigate a world far removed from the one I had known.
From the Marines, I moved on to Ohio State University, a significant step on a path that seemed improbable just years before. The cultural divide between my upbringing and the academic world was vast, a constant reminder of where I came from. Yet, I persevered, driven by a desire for something more. This journey culminated in my acceptance to Yale Law School, a place that felt worlds away from the trailer parks and factory towns of my youth. It was a testament to the power of personal resilience and the enduring, if sometimes fractured, support of family.
Looking back, I see how the decline of industry in the Rust Belt created a vacuum, leaving working-class families like mine feeling abandoned and without agency. There's a pervasive sense of learned helplessness, a tendency to blame external circumstances rather than taking personal responsibility. This cultural crisis, born from economic hardship and a crumbling social fabric, shaped not just my family, but an entire generation. My story is just one thread in that larger tapestry, a reflection of the challenges and the enduring spirit of a people often misunderstood.
My earliest memories are vivid with the presence of Mamaw and Papaw, my maternal grandparents, the bedrock in a turbulent sea. They had sought a better life after World War II, leaving behind the grinding poverty of Kentucky for the steel mills of Ohio, hoping to secure a middle-class future. Yet, the transition was never complete. The “hillbilly” ways, the feuds, the quick tempers, the struggles with alcohol and abuse, followed them, casting long shadows over subsequent generations. Mamaw, with her tough exterior and unwavering love, was a force of nature, capable of both terrifying rage and profound tenderness. She was the one who instilled in me a sense of discipline and a glimmer of hope that a different path was possible.
My mother, a bright woman in her own right, was caught in a relentless eddy of addiction and instability. Her relationships were a series of explosions and implosions, each one leaving more emotional debris in its wake. I watched as she battled her demons, and I often bore the brunt of the fallout. It was a painful cycle to witness, and even more so to live through, as the constant uncertainty chipped away at any sense of security. Despite her struggles, she worked hard as a nurse, trying to provide, but the chaos of her personal life often overshadowed her efforts.
The schools I attended reflected the brokenness around me. It was easy to fall into the trap of low expectations, to believe that my future was predetermined by my past. I dabbled in alcohol and weed, nearly failing my first year of high school. But somewhere amidst the turmoil, a flicker of ambition ignited, fueled by Mamaw's fierce belief in me and the stark realization that I did not want to repeat the patterns I saw everywhere. I spent a significant amount of time with Mamaw and my biological father, who, despite his own issues, offered a different kind of stability.
Joining the Marines after high school was a pivotal decision, a deliberate break from the familiar chaos. It offered structure, discipline, and a sense of purpose I hadn't known before. It was a chance to prove to myself, and to the world, that I could rise above my circumstances. The military taught me resilience and gave me the tools to navigate a world far removed from the one I had known.
From the Marines, I moved on to Ohio State University, a significant step on a path that seemed improbable just years before. The cultural divide between my upbringing and the academic world was vast, a constant reminder of where I came from. Yet, I persevered, driven by a desire for something more. This journey culminated in my acceptance to Yale Law School, a place that felt worlds away from the trailer parks and factory towns of my youth. It was a testament to the power of personal resilience and the enduring, if sometimes fractured, support of family.
Looking back, I see how the decline of industry in the Rust Belt created a vacuum, leaving working-class families like mine feeling abandoned and without agency. There's a pervasive sense of learned helplessness, a tendency to blame external circumstances rather than taking personal responsibility. This cultural crisis, born from economic hardship and a crumbling social fabric, shaped not just my family, but an entire generation. My story is just one thread in that larger tapestry, a reflection of the challenges and the enduring spirit of a people often misunderstood.
What other readers say
Liked
Reviewers widely praise the author's compelling writing style and the deeply personal nature of his memoir. Many found the book to be an essential and timely read, offering a unique "insider's" perspective on the challenges and cultural dynamics of growing up in Appalachia and the Rust Belt. The narrative is often described as inspirational, highlighting a journey of overcoming significant adversity, bolstered by strong familial bonds, particularly with his grandparents. Readers appreciated the candid and honest account of his experiences, which shed light on a segment of American society often misunderstood. The book is lauded for its ability to illuminate cultural divides and the specific hurdles faced by individuals from disadvantaged backgrounds navigating more elite environments, prompting readers to reflect on broader societal issues.
Disliked
Despite its strengths, the book draws considerable criticism. Several reviewers felt the author oversimplified the complex issues of poverty, focusing too heavily on individual responsibility and anecdotal evidence rather than exploring systemic economic or social factors. This led some to perceive a lack of empathy or a "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" message that they found naive or problematic. Concerns were also raised about the generalizability of the author's highly dysfunctional family experiences to the broader Appalachian culture, with some suggesting it reinforced negative stereotypes. Furthermore, some critics accused the book of skirting around issues of racism or offering insufficient analysis of its impact. Others found the book to be depressing, tedious, or felt its initial hype as a comprehensive explanation for complex political phenomena was ultimately misleading.
In short
Ultimately, reviews for this book are sharply divided, reflecting its controversial nature. While it is widely acknowledged as a well-written and emotionally impactful memoir of personal struggle and resilience, its broader sociological conclusions are a point of contention. The book is likely to resonate most with readers interested in deeply personal narratives and an "on-the-ground" look at specific American subcultures and their values. It is recommended for those who appreciate candid storytelling and are willing to engage with perspectives that may challenge their own, fostering thought and discussion on cultural identity and opportunity. However, readers seeking a comprehensive sociological or economic analysis of poverty, or a less individualized perspective on societal challenges, may find it less satisfying.
No reviews yet. Be the first.
Readers also liked


Machiavelli's the Prince : Text and Commentary
Niccolò Machiavelli

Angela's Ashes (The Frank McCourt Memoirs)
Frank McCourt

Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave
Frederick Douglass
Free to read

The Ego and Its Own The Case of The Individual Against Authority
John Carroll

The Global Encyclopaedia of Informality, Volume 1 Towards Understanding of Social and Cultural Complexity
Alena Ledeneva

Media Resistance Protest, Dislike, Abstention
Trine Syvertsen

Science in the Forest, Science in the Past
Aparecida Vilaça, Geoffrey E. R. Lloyd
![Cover of Hillbilly Elegy [movie Tie-In] A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis](https://images.isbndb.com/covers/11663993482210.jpg)




