Positives This book is widely praised for its expansive scope and the author's engaging perspective on music. Reviewers highlight its fascinating exploration of music's evolution, covering everything from its historical and technological development to its business aspects, cultural significance, and the psychology of listening. Many appreciate the author's unique insights into how performance spaces shape sound, the changing nature of the music industry, and his challenge to conventional notions of "high" versus "low" art. His writing style is frequently described as intelligent, curious, conversational, and witty, making complex topics accessible. The book is seen as inspiring, prompting readers to discover new music and even consider making their own, while also offering a frank look at the financial realities of being a musician.
Negatives However, some readers found the book to be uneven and occasionally lacking in depth. Criticisms include its tendency to skim over meaty subjects, presenting observations and opinions as facts without sufficient research or detailed exploration. The structure of the book is also mentioned as disjointed, with some feeling it jumps between topics too abruptly, resembling a collection of essays rather than a cohesive narrative. A few reviewers found the author's biases, particularly regarding classical music, to be annoying or naive. While personal anecdotes are present, some wished for either more in-depth technical detail about music creation or a more focused autobiography, rather than the blend presented.
Conclusion Overall, this book is recommended for anyone with a passion for music, from casual listeners to aspiring musicians, who are curious about its multifaceted nature. It offers a broad and thought-provoking perspective on how music functions in society, influenced by technology, culture, and business. While it may not satisfy those seeking a deeply academic treatise or a linear personal history, it serves as an excellent introduction to various aspects of the music world through the unique lens of a seasoned artist. Readers who appreciate an unconventional, reflective, and often inspiring take on the art form will likely find it a rewarding read.
