Hva visste hjemmefronten? Holocaust i Norge : varslene, unnvikelsene, hemmeligholdet

The book is widely praised for being well-written, engaging, and highly educational, offering readers significant new knowledge and a fresh perspective on a crucial historical period. Many reviewers commend the author for challenging long-held national narratives and deconstructing established truths, particularly concerning the role of the Norwegian resistance during World War II. It is described as a thought-provoking and important work that sheds light on issues such as historical passivity, the rapid spread of rumors against minority groups, and the pervasive antisemitism that existed in Norway and within resistance circles. Readers appreciate its ability to make complex historical material accessible and its relevance to contemporary issues, emphasizing the dangers of dehumanization and the importance of learning from history.

Despite its strengths, the book has been the subject of considerable debate and criticism. Several reviewers point out documented errors, inaccuracies, and issues with source citation, including instances of altered quotes. Some critics argue that these historical inaccuracies undermine the book's credibility, with a few even suggesting it should not have been published. Readers have noted that the controversy surrounding its methodology and sources can make it challenging to engage fully with the text. Minor criticisms also include a perceived lack of subheadings, some chapters being overly long, and a desire for more explicit discussion on the long-term consequences of historical oversight regarding Jewish deportations. For some, it was not as compelling or easy to read as the author's previous works, partly due to the extensive footnotes.

Ultimately, many readers consider this a vital and necessary book, despite the acknowledged criticisms regarding its factual precision. The core thesis - that widespread antisemitism contributed to the tragic fate of many Norwegian Jews and that more could have been done to save them - is seen by many as largely untouched by the debates. It is highly recommended for readers interested in a nuanced and critical examination of Norway's wartime history, particularly those willing to confront uncomfortable truths about national heroes and societal attitudes. This book will appeal to individuals who seek to challenge conventional historical narratives, gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of the past, and reflect on the enduring lessons of human responsibility and vigilance against prejudice. It encourages readers to engage critically with historical accounts and consider the broader context of events.