Positives Reviewers widely praise "Death at the Sanatorium" for its captivating and atmospheric setting. The isolated, haunting backdrop of an old tuberculosis sanatorium in northern Iceland, with its dark history and snowy chill, creates an irresistible and spooky ambiance that perfectly suits a Nordic Noir mystery. The book is lauded as a skillfully crafted, multi-timeline whodunit, frequently drawing comparisons to classic Golden Age detective fiction and Agatha Christie. Readers enjoyed the complex, engaging plot that unfolds across three distinct time periods, finding it a clever story and a real page-turner. The protagonist, Helgi, is described as a likable, persistent, and old-school detective, and the supporting cast of characters adds depth to the investigation. Many also appreciated the seamless translation and the author's ability to create a wonderfully dark atmosphere through calm, clean prose.
Negatives Despite its strengths, the book received some criticism, primarily concerning its ending. Numerous reviewers found the conclusion "abrupt," "very, very abrupt," or "WTF," leaving many loose ends and causing "whiplash." This often detracted from an otherwise enjoyable reading experience. Some readers also felt the pacing was "slow and plodding" or "a bit too long," particularly for those expecting a more intense thriller. Character development was occasionally noted as uneven, with some figures feeling like "bare sketches" or lacking distinct personalities, which made it difficult to fully grasp their motivations. A few reviewers also found the overall impact of the book somewhat "unforgettable" or "meh" and questioned the practical application of criminology in Helgi's dissertation, despite it being a central theme.
Conclusion Overall, "Death at the Sanatorium" is largely considered a strong and engaging mystery, often seen as a return to form for the author, even with its divisive ending. It successfully delivers a compelling cold case investigation wrapped in a rich, Icelandic atmosphere. This book is highly recommended for fans of Nordic Noir, especially those who appreciate a slow-burn police procedural over fast-paced action. Readers who enjoy Golden Age detective fiction, classic whodunits, and character-focused mysteries set in atmospheric, somewhat eerie locations will find much to like. While it contains subtle connections to the author's other series, it functions well as a standalone, making it accessible to new readers while offering familiar elements for existing fans. While the main mystery is concluded, some elements, particularly concerning the protagonist's personal life, are left unresolved, leading some to anticipate future installments.
