Positives Many readers found Sloane Crosley to be a smart, witty, and often hilarious writer, with her debut collection of essays prompting genuine laugh-out-loud moments. Reviewers praised her ability to craft engaging and lighthearted stories from everyday experiences, often appreciating her sardonic, self-deprecating humor. Several essays were highlighted as particularly strong, resonating with readers through their relatability to awkward social situations, professional mishaps, or quirky childhood memories. The book was frequently described as an enjoyable and quick read, serving as a pleasant "palate cleanser" between more substantial works. For many, Crosley's writing felt authentic and personable, making them feel as if they were connecting with a friend.
Negatives Despite its strengths, the collection received criticism for its uneven quality, with some essays failing to captivate readers. A significant number found the writing to be rambling, uninspired, or simply not funny, suggesting that the anecdotes might be more amusing to the author's personal friends than to a general audience. Some reviewers felt the author lacked sufficient meaningful life experiences to fill a book, leading to stretched material and a "so what?" reaction to many of the narratives. The humor was occasionally perceived as focusing on "upper-middle-class woes," making it less universally appealing. Critics also noted a perceived lack of authenticity or risk-taking in the writing, with some comparing it unfavorably to more established essayists and deeming it more akin to blog entries.
Conclusion Ultimately, "I Was Told There'd Be Cake" garners a mixed reception, standing out as a collection that strongly divides opinion. While some found it deeply relatable and thoroughly entertaining, others struggled to connect with its style or content. The book is most likely to appeal to young professionals, particularly women, who share a similar background of suburban upbringing and navigating life in a major city. Readers who appreciate dry, snarky, and self-aware humor, along with essays that explore the everyday neuroses and awkwardness of modern life, will likely find much to enjoy. However, those seeking profound insights, intense narratives, or a consistently groundbreaking comedic voice might find the collection to be merely "pretty good" rather than truly exceptional.
