Positives "Building a Character" is widely praised as an indispensable and highly influential work in the world of theater, offering profound insights and analytical tools for the craft of acting. Reviewers highlight its detailed strategies and exercises aimed at developing an actor's physicality, vocal versatility, and sense of timing and rhythm, ultimately fostering a sharp, expressive instrument. Many find its concepts on speech, diction, and character construction to be highly relatable and foundational to modern dramaturgy. Beyond acting, the book is recognized for its value to writers, particularly screenwriters and playwrights, for its unique perspective on character development, and even for general self-improvement in self-control and emotional depth. The latter chapters, in particular, are frequently cited as being very interesting and compelling.
Negatives However, many readers note that the book can be a challenging read. It is often described as highly technical, detailed, and at times tedious, particularly when compared to its more inspiring predecessor, "An Actor Prepares." Reviewers mention struggling with certain sections, finding some instructions repetitive or difficult to fully grasp from text alone, especially concepts like tempo-rhythms or specific physical and vocal exercises. The consensus is that some of the detailed work, such as rhythm exercises or complex word breakdowns, almost necessitates in-person experience or guidance to be fully understood and applied effectively. The language can also be dense, and some feel it over-explains simpler concepts while vital ones remain harder to implement without an "expert eye."
Conclusion Despite these challenges, "Building a Character" is considered an essential and rewarding read for those truly serious about acting and theater. It is recommended for aspiring actors, theater students, and anyone pursuing a career in performance, serving as a crucial component of Stanislavski's method. Playwrights and screenwriters will also find it beneficial for deepening their understanding of character creation. The overall verdict suggests that while it demands perseverance and may be best complemented by practical classes, the utility of its teachings for developing a credible, natural, and expressive character makes the effort entirely worthwhile, providing a vital foundation for modern artistic training.
