Indonesia optimis

The book addresses significant issues such as corruption in Indonesia and offers a comparison between the New Order and post-reform eras. It is noted for presenting its arguments with data, providing a factual basis for its discussions on these important historical and political periods.

However, a consistent criticism across reviews is the book's perceived lack of objectivity and clear bias. Readers observe a strong partiality towards the SBY administration, suggesting the author may be protective of it. The book is seen as primarily highlighting only the positive achievements during SBY's leadership, leading to the impression that it might function as a tool for image-building rather than a balanced analysis.

In summary, while the book tackles crucial political and historical subjects, its pronounced bias towards a specific government is a significant point of contention. This book would likely be of interest to readers seeking a particular viewpoint on Indonesia's political environment, especially concerning the SBY era, or those wishing to understand corruption and reform from a perspective that emphasizes the positive aspects of that period. Readers looking for a strictly neutral, comprehensive, and balanced analysis, however, may find the book's approach less satisfying.