Iran Jameeye Koutah Moddat (Persian Edition)

The reviews frequently praise the book for offering a fresh and enlightening perspective on Iran's historical and political development. Many readers found it concise, well-reasoned, and supported by historical documentation, making it an excellent starting point for understanding significant issues like Iran's historical patterns and challenges in long-term planning. The book is lauded for raising important questions and providing a general overview of complex topics without being overly academic or dense. Its readability and ability to encourage further exploration of Iranian history and sociology are consistently highlighted as strong positives, with several reviewers finding particular articles insightful and thought-provoking. The quality of the translation is also mentioned favorably by some, contributing to the book's accessibility.

However, several reviewers point out structural and conceptual weaknesses. A common criticism is the significant repetition of content, particularly between the first and second articles, which some found made the reading experience tedious. As a collection of essays, the book is often noted for lacking the comprehensive depth expected of a full-length study, leaving some questions unanswered or arguments feeling underdeveloped. Critics also argue that the central theory of a "short-term society" could be more thoroughly explained, with some suggesting it might be a consequence rather than a primary cause of Iran's historical trajectory. Additionally, a few reviewers found some of the author's general statements about Iranian society to be overly broad or to draw strong conclusions from limited historical evidence. One review also mentioned issues with the physical book's editing, noting missing words.

Overall, "Iran: The Short-Term Society" is seen as a valuable contribution for introducing key concepts and theories about Iran's historical challenges, despite its limitations as a collection of articles. While it may not satisfy readers seeking an exhaustive academic study, it serves as an excellent entry point for those new to the sociology and contemporary history of Iran. The book is particularly recommended for young readers or anyone curious about the underlying reasons behind Iran's historical developments and persistent societal patterns, hoping to foster a deeper understanding that could help avoid past mistakes. It is best approached as an introductory text that provides thought-provoking ideas and a framework for further, more detailed study.